Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita (comparative study)
by Ranjni M. | 2013 | 54,094 words
This page relates ‘Svatantrya of Shiva� of study dealing with Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita. This thesis presents a comparative analysis of two non-dualistic philosophies, Pratyabhijna from Kashmir and Shankara’s Advaita Vedanta from Kerala, highlighting their socio-cultural backgrounds and philosophical similarities..
Go directly to: Footnotes.
3.1. ٲԳٰⲹ of Ś
[Full title: Special Features of Ś and Brahman (1): ٲԳٰⲹ of Ś]
Besides the similarities, both ultimate realities of ʰٲⲹñ and Advaita Vedānta bear some distinctive features also. Among them ٲԳٰ and ṛt of Ś, and Akartṛtā of Brahman are important. Even though Brahman is also considered as independent (Svatantra), there is some peculiarity in the notion of ٲԳٰⲹ in ʰٲⲹñ.
ʲś, the supreme reality of ʰٲⲹñ, is characterized with consciousness and freedom (Cit and ٲԳٰⲹ). This special feature distinguishes ʲś from Brahman. While commenting the word ‘Svatantra� in the ūٰ, پ� svatantrā viśvasiddhihetu�, Kśemarāja has clarified this fact:
svatantraśabdo brahmavādavailakṣaṇya� ācakṣāṇa� cito māheśvaryasāratā� brūte |[1]
Utpala points out that the sovereignty (śⲹ) of Ѳś is his power of freedom itself:
پ� pratyavamarśātmā parāvāksvarasoditā |
svātantryametanmukhya� tadaiśvarya� paramātmana� || [2]
While explaining this , Abhinavagupta says that the bliss, freedom, consciousness etc. are synonyms of ʲś’s independent nature:
anyanirapekṣataiva paramārthata� ԲԻ岹�, aiśvaryam, ٲԳٰⲹ�, caitanyam |[3]
ٲԳٰⲹ of Ѳś is the freedom in uniting, separating and in holding together.
It consists in not being self-confined like the insentient; in having as its essential nature unlimited light; in perfect independence:
ٲԳٰⲹ� saṃyojanaviyojanānusaṃndhānādirūpa� ātmamātratāyāmeva jaḍavat aviśrāntatva� aparicchinnaprakāśasāratva� ananyamukhaprekṣitva� ceti |[4]
ʲś, using the wonderful freedom of his monistic self, can and does create and bring into existence all phenomenal actions. His self is not at all devoid of independence all through the process of the amazing conception and manifestation of the universe. These powers of knowing (Բū ñԲśپ�) and doing (ܱū śپ�) in accordance with his free will, inherently exist in ʲś. All living beings are endowed with the same powers.
Utpala says thus:
svātantryāmuktamātmāna� svātantryādadvayātmana� |
prabhurīśādisaṃkalpairnirmāya vyavahārayet ||
ata eva yathābhīṣṭasamullekhāvabhāsanam |
jñānakriye sphuṭe eva siddhe sarvasya jīvata� || [5]
Thus it is clear that the ٲԳٰⲹ of ʲś is closely associated with his Jñātṛtva (sentiency) and ṛt (subjectivity).
Footnotes and references:
[1]:
ʰٲⲹñhṛdaya� of ṣeᲹ, p. 5.
[4]:
Ibid., p. 247f.
[5]:
Īśٲⲹñ-, 1.5.16 & 1.6.11.