Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita (comparative study)
by Ranjni M. | 2013 | 54,094 words
This page relates ‘Categories in Pratyabhijna and Advaita� of study dealing with Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita. This thesis presents a comparative analysis of two non-dualistic philosophies, Pratyabhijna from Kashmir and Shankara’s Advaita Vedanta from Kerala, highlighting their socio-cultural backgrounds and philosophical similarities..
Go directly to: Footnotes.
2. Categories in ʰٲⲹñ and Advaita
All philosophical systems generally categorize the reality in order to understand a complete picture of the macrocosm and microcosm. In ʰٲⲹñ philosophy the universe is the self manifested form of ʲś. ʲś with his own powers of free will, knowledge and action creates the universe within himself. The manifestation is comprised of thirty six categories (Tattvas) from Ś to earth. A Tattva is a single and indivisible constituent of the diverse universe.[1] Even though the Advaita Vedānta texts do not give such a numbered division, similar categorical beings can be seen in Advaita also.
The 36 Tattvas of ʰٲⲹñ are:
And 25 principles accepted by ṅkⲹ:
- ʰṛt,
- ʳܰṣa,
- Mahat,
- ṅk,
- Manas,
- Five organs of knowledge,
- Five organs of action,
- Five subtle elements and
- Five gross elements.[2]
As ʰٲⲹñ, Advaita also accepts the 25 principles of ṅkⲹ with slight difference. ʳܰṣa is ī, which is ultimately Brahman itself. ʰṛt, which is Triguṇātmikā and Avyakta, is also there in Advaita. It is described as the Brahman itself, the Upādānakāraṇa and ٳٲṇa of the universe[3] or the power of Brahman.[4] ʰṛt is also described as the subtle elements, which have the potential for diversified creation. Out of other 23 categories, except ṅk, all are accepted separately.
Similar to the five sheaths of , in Advaita also there are five sheaths or ś, which are:
In connection with these ś of the embodied being, there are six categories of conscious beings, viz.
- Īś (ñԲ-ṣṭ-upahita),
- ʰñ (ñԲ-ⲹṣṭ-upahita),
- ᾱṇy or Sūtratma (ūṣmśī-ṣṭ-upahita),
- Taijasa (ūṣmśī-vyaṣṭyu-pahita),
- ղśԲ or Virāt (ٳūśī-ṣṭ-upahita),
- վś (ٳūśī-ⲹṣṭ-upahita).
In both systems the ultimate Principle is above all these categories.
Footnotes and references:
[1]:
[2]:
Vide supra, p. 53-56.
[4]:
mahato'pi 貹� ūṣmٲ� pratyagātmabhūta� sarvamahattara� ca ⲹٲ� sarvasya jagato bījabhūtamavyākṛtanāmarūpa� satatva� sarvakāryakāraṇaśaktisamāhārarūpa� avyaktam avyākṛtākāśādināmavācya� paramātmanyotaprotabhāvena śٲ� vaṭakaṇikāyāmiva vaṭavṛkṣaśakti� | ṻDZ貹Ծṣa-śṅk-ṣy, 3.11; māyā triguṇātmikā avidyālakṣaṇ� ṛt� ūⲹٱ ܳٱ岹ⲹپ 峦� jagat | 岵ī-śṅk-ṣy, 9.10; avyaktnāmnī parameśaśakti� anādyavidyā triguṇātmikā 貹 | kāryānumeyā sudhiyaiva māyā ⲹ jagatsarvamida� praūⲹٱ || Viveka-ūḍāmṇi, 110.
[5]:
Vide ղٳپīDZ貹Ծṣa and ղٳپīDZ貹Ծṣa-śṅk-ṣy, 2.2-5.