365bet

Tattvabindu of Vachaspati Mishra (study)

by Kishor Deka | 2024 | 49,069 words

This page relates ‘Date of Vacaspati Mishra� of the English study of the Tattvabindu by Vachaspati Mishra (study)—a significant text in the Mimamsa philosophy which addresses the concept of verbal knowledge (shabdabodha) and identifies the efficient cause behind it, examining five traditional perspectives. These are Sphota-Vada, Varna-Vada, Varnamala-Vada, and Anvitabhidhana-Vada and Abhihitanvaya-Vada, with the Tattvabindu primarily endorsing the Abhihitanvayavada view.

Go directly to: Footnotes.

Part 3.1 - Date of 峦貹پ Ѿś

峦貹پ Ѿś’s date is fixed by scholars from the references found in his works. In his work ⲹūīԾԻ, which is regarded as an appendix to his ٱ貹ⲹṭīk, he has given the date of completion of that work 898 Vikrama era which is equivalent to 841 A.D.[1] Here, the question arises about the era of this date. There is a great deal of debate whether this is Ś첹 era or Vikrama era. If it is Ś첹 era, then the date will be 976 A.D. and on the other hand, if it is Vikrama era, then the date will be 841 A.D. Therefore, a proper study of external and internal sources is needed for correctly determining the date of 峦貹پ Ѿś.

In addition to the date provided by him in ⲹūīԾԻ, the following data are also provided by him in his works:

(i) In his Advaita Vedāntic work 峾ī, he has mentioned the name of king ṛg.[2]
(ii) 峦貹پ Ѿś has referred to ⲹñᲹī in his work.[3]
(iii) He has refuted 첹峦ⲹ in his 峾ī, who belongs to 800 or 900 A.D.[4]
(iv) In his ٱ貹ⲹṭīk, 峦貹پ has quoted Dharmottara twice, whose time is said to be 900 A.D.[5]

On the other hand, 岹ⲹ峦ⲹ (about 984 A.D) commented upon 峦貹پ Ѿś’s ⲹٳپ첹ٱ貹ⲹṭīk under the name Բⲹٳپ첹ٱ貹ⲹṭīk貹śܻ. So, it is clear that the upper limit of 峦貹پ’s date cannot be later than 984 A.D. From the reference to king ṛg given by 峦貹پ Ѿś, let us see what is the true identity of his king. S.N. Dasgupta has given his own views that there is no epigraphical reference of a king named ṛg.

In his words,

“This king, so far as the present writer is aware, has yet been historically traced.�[6]

But, in this regard, Gaṅgānāth Jhā disagrees with Dasgupta. According to his view, ṛg was a real king of Ѿٳ󾱱, a predecessor of king Nānyadeva who was known to have ruled his kingdom about 1019 Vikrama era, i.e. 962 A.D.[7] This evidence of king ṛg may be regarded as conclusive since even ԲԻ岹 in his ձԳٲ Kalpataru mentions ṛg as the petron of 峦貹پ Ѿś.[8] Again, the opinion of the point that 峦貹پ referred to ⲹñᲹī is somewhat confusing. Jayanta ṭṭ, the famous writer of ⲹñᲹī belongs to the 10th century A.D. As such, 峦貹پ Ѿś’s date cannot fall before 10th century A.D. But actually the ⲹñᲹī referred to by 峦貹پ Ѿś is not the ⲹñᲹī written by Jayanta ṭṭ. On the contrary, the ⲹñᲹī was written by Trilocana who was his guru.

From the above discussion it can be concluded that 峦貹پ Ѿś lived in the year 898 Vikrama era, which is equivalent to 841 A.D. as mentioned in his works.

In the words of V.N. Sheshagiri Rao,

“All these go to show that 峦貹پ lived in all approximate certainty not earlier or later than the period 841-900 A.D.�[9]

Footnotes and references:

[back to top]

[1]:

ԲⲹūīԾԻ’yپ ṣāṃ mude /
śrīvācaspatimiśreṇa vasvaṅkavasuvatsare // History of Indian Philosophy , Vol. I, p.107

[2]:

nareśvarā yaccaritānukāramicchanti kartu� na ca pārayanti/
tasminmahīpe mahanīyakīrtau śrīmannṛge� ԾԻ� // 峾ī on Br. SSBH , Vol.2, p. 1020

[3]:

ⲹ첹ṇi , p. 257

[4]:

Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies. , Vol. 2, p. 454

[5]:

A History of Indian Logic , p. 329

[6]:

History of Indian Philosophy , Vol. 2, p. 107

[7]:

Sanskrit Introduction to Sāṃkhyatattvakaumudī , p. 2

[8]:

峾ī on Br. SSBH , Vol. 2, p. 1021

[9]:

峦貹پ’s Contribution to Advaita , p. 7

Let's grow together!

I humbly request your help to keep doing what I do best: provide the world with unbiased sources, definitions and images. Your donation direclty influences the quality and quantity of knowledge, wisdom and spiritual insight the world is exposed to.

Let's make the world a better place together!

Like what you read? Help to become even better: