Are we failing our students�.by passing them?
Journal name: Journal of Indian Society of Periodontology
Original article title: Are we failing our students�.by passing them?
The Journal of Indian Society of Periodontology (JISP) publishes original scientific articles on periodontology (the study of supporting structures of teeth) and oral implantology. It is a bimonthly open-access journal with special issues for specific occasions.
This page presents a generated summary with additional references; See source (below) for actual content.
Original source:
This page is merely a summary which is automatically generated hence you should visit the source to read the original article which includes the author, publication date, notes and references.
Nitin Dani
Journal of Indian Society of Periodontology:
(A bimonthly open-access journal)
Full text available for: Are we failing our students�.by passing them?
Year: 2018 | Doi: 10.4103/jisp.jisp_405
Copyright (license): CC BY-NC-SA
Summary of article contents:
Introduction
The time of examinations in India brings considerable stress and tension for post-graduate students, as they prepare to culminate their studies with practical and theoretical tests. Despite the overwhelming pressure, a surprising observation arises: the vast majority of students succeed, often achieving high marks in their practical examinations. This trend raises critical questions about the quality of education and the processes in place that seemingly allow for such remarkable success rates without significant failure.
The Illusion of Success
The crux of the issue lies in whether passing students at such high rates is truly beneficial or if it creates a false sense of expertise among graduates. The author suggests that the current educational practices may enable improper collaborations among various stakeholders—teachers, college authorities, and examiners—which compromise the integrity of postgraduate medical training. This results in graduates who may lack the essential skills and clinical capabilities expected of them, ultimately diluting their education's value. By promoting a system where high marks are prioritized over actual competency, it risks producing “qualified quacks� instead of proficient professionals.
Conclusion
In light of these concerns, it is imperative for educators to reflect on their roles and responsibilities within this system. The call for introspection challenges teachers to consider whether they are truly fulfilling their noble profession and serving society by passing students without adequately assessing their abilities. The sustainability of medical education hinges on quality control and the necessity of creating skilled professionals who are equipped to make meaningful contributions to their fields, rather than merely completing a program without substantive learning.
FAQ section (important questions/answers):
What is the primary concern regarding MDS practical examinations in India?
The primary concern is that very few students fail MDS practical exams, leading to questions about the validity of their qualifications and whether they truly possess the skills required in clinical practice.
How do teachers feel about the current examination grading system?
Teachers feel pressured to provide high results to students, often leading to a lack of quality control in education, which in turn may compromise the integrity of the profession and the true efficacy of the education provided.
What does the text suggest about the role of teachers?
The text suggests that teachers should inspire and ensure students truly comprehend and master their subjects, as they play a crucial role in shaping future professionals and society at large.
Why is there a disparity between student capabilities and examination results?
The disparity arises from a system where students are easily passed to meet demands from college authorities and parents, rather than a fair assessment of their true capabilities and readiness for professional practice.
What is the potential outcome of passing students without proper evaluation?
Passing students without adequate evaluation may lead to the creation of inadequately prepared professionals who require supervision even after graduation, thereby risking public trust in the profession.
Glossary definitions and references:
Scientific and Ayurvedic Glossary list for “Are we failing our students�.by passing them?�. This list explains important keywords that occur in this article and links it to the glossary for a better understanding of that concept in the context of Ayurveda and other topics.
1) Post:
Post refers to the stage after completion of an undergraduate degree, particularly in the context of postgraduate studies. This level of education, which includes master's degrees like MDS in various fields, is significant for advanced skills and expertise, highlighting a student’s commitment to their professional development in a specialized area.
2) Education:
Education serves as a foundation for personal and professional growth, equipping individuals with necessary skills, knowledge, and critical thinking. The text emphasizes the pivotal role of education in shaping the future, raising questions about the effectiveness of educational standards and the implications of passing students without sufficient competency.
3) India:
India's educational landscape is characterized by a highly competitive environment, particularly during examination periods. The text reflects on how societal and systemic pressures affect students' experiences and outcomes, highlighting the implications of educational practices in India, where passing rates are unexpectedly high and raise concerns about quality and true competency.
4) Scratching:
The term 'scratching' refers to the practice of reciprocally helping one another, often seen in contexts where collegiality may lead to compromised integrity. In the text, it symbolizes the potential collusion between college authorities and examiners to inflate student results, raising ethical questions about true merit in academia.
5) Teaching:
Teaching is presented as a noble profession with significant responsibilities. It shapes individuals' characters and future potentials, affirming that educators have the power to influence not only academic outcomes but also societal well-being. The text emphasizes the necessity for teachers to guide and inspire students genuinely to maintain educational integrity.
6) Sweating (Sweat):
Sweating symbolizes the stress and anxiety faced by students during exam seasons, depicting a broader emotional context linked to performance pressures. The text illustrates how this stress is not due to external conditions, but their overwhelming responsibility to succeed, thus revealing a flawed educational system that fosters unnecessary pressure.
7) Quality:
Quality pertains to the standards of education and the competence of graduates. The text points out the paradox of high pass rates and academic achievements in practical exams, questioning the true quality of education offered and whether it genuinely prepares students for professional roles, reflecting on the broader implications for society.
8) Flying:
Flying signifies achieving remarkably high standards, as depicted in the context of students passing with 'flying colors.' This expression illustrates the tendency for inflated results, thereby calling into question the authenticity and competency of those who might not truly meet the expectations of their professional roles.
9) Kalam:
A. P. J. Abdul Kalam, mentioned in the text, symbolizes excellence in educational thought and moral integrity. His views on teaching being a noble profession serve as a benchmark for educators, urging a reflection on the moral responsibilities they hold and the extent to which they fulfill their pivotal role in shaping society.
10) Party:
Party signifies the celebratory atmosphere post-examinations, representing relief and joy. However, despite the festivities associated with results, the text subtly critiques this mentality by questioning the true preparedness and competence of graduates, emphasizing the need for deeper introspection about what these celebrations signify professionally.
11) Sah:
Shah Rukh Khan, quoted in the text, serves as a cultural reference illustrating the idea that failure cultivates humility. By invoking his words, the text encourages students and educators alike to consider the valuable lessons learned from setbacks, challenging the tendency to equate success solely with high grades or accolades.
12) Fear:
Fear reflects the psychological barriers that educators face within the academic environment, particularly regarding job security and the apprehension to judge students truthfully. The text illustrates how such fear can lead to a complacent educational system, compromising the integrity of teaching and ultimately the quality of education.
13) Fire:
Fire symbolizes the urgency and passion behind the need for educational reform. It serves as a metaphor for the intensity of the discussions around the necessity for teachers to self-reflect and commit to improving their practices. The burning issues highlighted challenge the status quo and urge activism within the educational sphere.
14) Pur:
Poor denotes the subpar standards of education and student performance that are often masked by high pass rates. The text emphasizes a concern for students who, despite passing, may lack essential skills. This notion conveys a need for educators to foster genuine learning rather than superficial assessments.
15) Life:
Life encapsulates the broader journey that education influences, intertwining personal fulfillment and professional aspirations. The text underscores the importance of quality education in shaping successful lives, arguing that failing to adequately prepare students through meaningful assessments could lead to detrimental societal impacts and unqualified practitioners.
Other Science Concepts:
Discover the significance of concepts within the article: �Are we failing our students�.by passing them?�. Further sources in the context of Science might help you critically compare this page with similair documents:
Great teacher, Good teacher, Quality Control, Mediocre teacher, Superior teacher.
Concepts being referred in other categories, contexts and sources.