ID of Arjuna, Punarnava, Jatamansi: Substitution and Adulteration
Journal name: Ayushdhara
Original article title: Pharmacognostical Identification of Arjuna, Punarnava and Jatamansi with Recapture of Concept of Substitution and Adulteration
AYUSHDHARA is an international peer-reviewed journal. It focuses on research in Ayurveda, Yoga, Unani, Siddha, Homeopathy, Allopathy, and Pharmaceutical Sciences.
This page presents a generated summary with additional references; See source (below) for actual content.
Original source:
This page is merely a summary which is automatically generated hence you should visit the source to read the original article which includes the author, publication date, notes and references.
Swati Goyal
A.M.O., Govt. of Rajasthan, Rajasthan, India.
Nitin Verma
Program Manager, Ministry of AYUSH, Delhi, India.
Ayushdhara:
(A peer-reviewed, bi-monthly open-access journal)
Full text available for: Pharmacognostical Identification of Arjuna, Punarnava and Jatamansi with Recapture of Concept of Substitution and Adulteration
Year: 2023 | Doi: 10.47070/ayushdhara.v10iSuppl1.1165
Copyright (license): CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Download the PDF file of the original publication
Summary of article contents:
Introduction
The Ayurvedic medical system has gained global significance as people increasingly seek herbal remedies and Ayurvedic therapies. This rising trend has led to an exponential increase in the demand for Ayurvedic medicines. However, the practices of adulteration and substitution of herbal raw materials have emerged as significant concerns, threatening the integrity and efficacy of Ayurvedic treatments. These practices often result from insufficient raw material, economic incentives, and the morphological similarity of herbs, making it challenging to distinguish between authentic and adulterated substances.
The Concept of Adulteration
Adulteration refers to the practice of substituting original herbal drugs with inferior or harmful substances, which compromises their therapeutic qualities. The article discusses various types of adulteration, including deliberate adulteration (intentional mix of mostly inferior products) and undeliberate adulteration (unintentional contamination or substitution). The authors highlight the reasons for such practices, which include problematic collection methods, imperfect preparation techniques, confusion around vernacular names, and lack of knowledge regarding authentic plant sources. These elements collectively contribute to the deterioration of the quality of Ayurvedic medicines, raising concerns about the potential adverse effects on consumers.
The Concept of Substitution
Substitution is a practice recognized in Ayurveda, involving the use of alternative substances when the original drug is unavailable. Such replacements are made based on the similarity of fundamental properties and therapeutic actions. Ayurvedic classics provide guidelines on selecting substitute drugs, which should ideally maintain comparable medicinal effects. The article outlines different types of substitutions, including those of species within the same family or entirely different substances that serve similar medical purposes. While substitution can sometimes be justified, it often raises ethical questions and concerns regarding quality and efficacy.
Conclusion
The growth in the Ayurvedic sector presents both challenges and opportunities, especially concerning adulteration and substitution. The authors advocate for strategic planning, supply chain management, and education for suppliers and traders to enhance awareness of authentic sources. They emphasize the need for pharmacovigilance, knowledge sharing, and adherence to regulatory guidelines, like those from the World Health Organization, to maintain the quality of Ayurvedic medicines. By addressing these issues, the integrity of the Ayurvedic system can be preserved, ensuring that consumers receive safe and effective herbal therapies.
FAQ section (important questions/answers):
What is the aim of the pharmacognostical study discussed?
The aim is to identify Arjuna, Punarnava, and Jatamansi, highlighting issues around adulteration and substitution, while exploring the causes and types associated with these practices in the herbal trade.
What are the key issues related to herbal adulteration?
Key issues include deforestation, insufficient knowledge about herbal materials, and unauthenticated practices, which collectively threaten the integrity of Ayurvedic medicines, often leading to health risks for consumers.
What types of substitution and adulteration are mentioned?
Substitution may involve using similar drugs or completely different substances, while adulteration can involve mixing inferior materials or failing to meet quality standards, negatively impacting therapeutic efficacy.
Glossary definitions and references:
Scientific and Ayurvedic Glossary list for 鈥淚D of Arjuna, Punarnava, Jatamansi: Substitution and Adulteration鈥�. This list explains important keywords that occur in this article and links it to the glossary for a better understanding of that concept in the context of Ayurveda and other topics.
1) Drug:
A drug refers to a substance or combination of substances intended for use in the diagnosis, treatment, or prevention of diseases. In this context, drugs like Arjuna and Punarnava are studied for their pharmacognostical properties to ensure quality assurance and prevent adulteration and substitution in Ayurveda.
2) Punarnava (Punar-nava):
Punarnava is a medicinal plant known botanically as Boerhavia diffusa. It is examined here for its pharmacognostical properties to differentiate it from adulterants like Trianthema portulacastrum. It plays a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of Ayurvedic medicine by preventing fraudulent substitutions.[see source text or glossary: Punarnava]
3) Pharmacognostical:
Pharmacognostical studies involve the identification of medicinal plants and raw drugs based on physical, chemical, morphological, and histological properties. This article investigates the pharmacognostical characteristics of medicinal plants like Arjuna, Punarnava, and Jatamansi to prevent adulteration and ensure the efficacy of Ayurvedic medicines.[see source text or glossary: Pharmacognostical]
4) Arjuna:
Arjuna, botanically known as Terminalia arjuna, is an important medicinal plant in Ayurveda. The bark is primarily used, characterized by its astringent taste. The pharmacognostical study differentiates it from adulterants like Terminalia alata to ensure the authenticity and therapeutic quality of the drug.[see source text or glossary: Arjuna]
5) Substance:
A substance refers to any material or matter. In the context of this text, it includes raw medicinal materials which are sometimes subject to adulteration or substitution, compromising their purity and therapeutic efficacy. Ensuring the right substance is used is critical in Ayurvedic medicine.[see source text or glossary: Substance]
6) Nardostachys jatamansi (Nardostachys jatamamsi):
Nardostachys jatamansi is a medicinal plant known for its characteristic bitter taste and aromatic properties. The study investigates its pharmacognostical features to distinguish it from similar substances like Valeriana wallichi and Selinum vaginatum, ensuring that the correct herb is used in Ayurvedic treatments.[see source text or glossary: Nardostachys jatamansi]
7) Terminalia arjuna:
Terminalia arjuna is the botanical name for Arjuna, a plant with significant therapeutic importance in Ayurveda. The quality and identification of its bark are discussed to prevent adulteration with inferior species like Terminalia alata, ensuring authentic and effective Ayurvedic medicine.[see source text or glossary: Terminalia arjuna]
8) Ayurveda (Ayus-veda):
Ayurveda is a traditional system of medicine originating in India, utilizing plant-based treatments. It emphasizes holistic health and balance. This text discusses pharmacognostical identification in Ayurveda to maintain the integrity of its medicinal practices and avoid adulteration and substitution.[see source text or glossary: Ayurveda]
9) Bitter:
Bitter refers to one of the tastes in Ayurveda and is a key sensory characteristic used for identifying certain medicinal plants. For instance, both Nardostachys jatamansi and its substitutes exhibit a bitter taste which aids in pharmacognostical identification.[see source text or glossary: Bitter]
10) Knowledge:
Knowledge in this context refers to the information and skills acquired through experience or education regarding the identification, collection, and use of medicinal plants. Sharing this knowledge, particularly about authentic sources, is essential to counteract adulteration and substitution in Ayurvedic medicine.[see source text or glossary: Knowledge]
11) Medicine:
Medicine in Ayurveda includes herbal mixtures and plant-based treatments used for health management. The study of pharmacognostical identification is crucial in ensuring that these medicines are pure, potent, and effective, without any adulteration or substitution.[see source text or glossary: Medicine]
12) Family:
Family refers to the botanical family that a medicinal plant belongs to. For instance, Terminalia arjuna belongs to the Combretaceae family. Correctly identifying the family aids in authenticating the plant and preventing adulteration.[see source text or glossary: Family]
13) Sanskrit:
Sanskrit is the classical language in which many Ayurvedic texts are written. The names of many medicinal plants, such as Punarnava (Boerhavia diffusa), are derived from Sanskrit, which helps in authenticating and studying these plants pharmacognostically.[see source text or glossary: Sanskrit]
14) Bhaishajya (Bhaisajya):
Bhaishajya refers to medicinal preparations in Ayurveda. The term is used in classical texts such as Bhaishajya Ratnavali, which provides guidelines on the use of herbs and substitutes in Ayurvedic medicine, highlighting the importance of avoiding adulteration for effective treatment.[see source text or glossary: Bhaishajya]
15) Discussion:
Discussion in the article covers the issues of adulteration and substitution in Ayurvedic practices, the pharmacognostical studies undertaken, and recommendations for integrated approaches to ensure authenticity and high quality of medicinal plants like Arjuna, Punarnava, and Jatamansi.[see source text or glossary: Discussion]
16) Rajasthan:
Rajasthan is mentioned in the context of Swati Goyal, one of the authors who is an Ayurvedic Medical Officer in the Government of Rajasthan. This indicates the regional expertise and contribution to the study of Ayurvedic pharmacognosy.[see source text or glossary: Rajasthan]
17) Evolution:
Evolution in this context refers to the changes and adaptations in plant species over time, which can affect their identification and therapeutic properties. Pharmacognostical studies help in understanding these changes to prevent adulteration with evolved or different plant species.[see source text or glossary: Evolution]
18) Vagbhata:
Vagbhata is one of the classical authors of Ayurveda, whose works provide significant information on the substitution of medicinal herbs. His guidelines help in modern practices to choose appropriate substitutes when original drugs are unavailable.[see source text or glossary: Vagbhata]
19) Jaggery:
Jaggery is mentioned as an example in the context of substitution. If old jaggery is not available, new jaggery can be sun-dried for use, illustrating how substitutions can maintain the efficacy of Ayurvedic preparations.[see source text or glossary: Jaggery]
20) Dravya:
Dravya in Ayurveda refers to substances or materials used for therapeutic purposes. Understanding the correct dravya is essential to prevent adulteration and ensure the effectiveness of Ayurvedic medicines.[see source text or glossary: Dravya]
21) Ashoka (Asoka):
Ashoka refers to a medicinal plant often substituted by other barks such as those from Treena orientials. Correct identification through pharmacognostical methods helps in ensuring the right Ashoka bark is used in treatments.[see source text or glossary: Ashoka]
22) Powder:
Powder refers to the form in which many medicinal plants are used. Powders are particularly susceptible to adulteration, making accurate pharmacognostical identification important to ensure they are genuine and effective.[see source text or glossary: Powder]
23) Karma (Karman):
Karma in Ayurveda refers to the therapeutic action or effect of a drug. The article discusses how substitution is chosen based on karma to ensure that the substitute has similar therapeutic effects as the original drug.[see source text or glossary: Karma]
24) India:
India is the origin and hub of Ayurvedic medicine. The article highlights the need for proper regulation and quality control in India to prevent adulteration and ensure the authenticity of Ayurvedic herbs and practices.[see source text or glossary: India]
25) Ayus (Ayush):
Ayush is referenced in the context of Nitin Verma, a program manager with the Ministry of AYUSH, India, indicating institutional involvement in addressing issues related to adulteration and substitution in Ayurvedic medicine.[see source text or glossary: Ayush]
26) Emblica officinalis:
Emblica officinalis, also known as Amalaki, is highlighted as a substitute for Bhallatak for Rasayan karma. This illustrates the concept of using plants with similar therapeutic actions when the primary herb is unavailable.[see source text or glossary: Emblica officinalis]
27) Tribulus terrestris:
Tribulus terrestris, known as Laghu Gokshur, is used as a substitute for Padalium murex, showing how plants within the same family can be substituted for each other based on similar properties and efficacy.[see source text or glossary: Tribulus terrestris]
28) Pratinidhi:
Pratinidhi Dravyas are substitute drugs in Ayurveda used when the original drug is unavailable. This concept helps maintain therapeutic efficacy while addressing issues of unavailability and avoiding adulteration.[see source text or glossary: Pratinidhi]
29) Kantakari (Kamtakari):
Kantakari (Solanum xanthocarpum) is mentioned as a substitute for Bharangi in respiratory diseases, demonstrating the practice of substitution in Ayurveda to maintain treatment efficacy.[see source text or glossary: Kantakari]
30) Lakshmana (Laksmana):
Lakshmana is a herb with uncertain identity, leading to different species like Aralia quinquefolia and Ipomea sepiaria being considered as substitutes, underscoring the importance of accurate pharmacognostical identification.[see source text or glossary: Lakshmana]
31) Ashtavarga (Astavarga, Ashtan-varga):
Astavarga dravyas are essential medicinal plants often facing non-availability, necessitating the use of substitutes to ensure continuity in Ayurvedic treatments.[see source text or glossary: Astavarga]
32) Liquorice (Licorice):
Liquorice is often subject to adulteration, such as mixing with exhausted drug parts. Ensuring the quality involves identifying and removing such adulterants to maintain its medicinal properties.[see source text or glossary: Liquorice]
33) Kusumbha (Kushumbha):
Kusumbha is used as a substitute for Kumkum due to cost considerations, illustrating how substitutions can help manage the economic aspects without compromising on therapeutic efficacy.[see source text or glossary: Kusumbha]
34) Bharangi (Bharamgi):
Bharangi (Clerodendron indicum) is used interchangeably with Kantakari for respiratory ailments, demonstrating a common practice in Ayurveda of using functional substitutes.[see source text or glossary: Bharangi]
35) Shaileya (Saileya):
Shaileya (Pamelia perlata) is often mixed with other species due to careless collection, highlighting the need for proper pharmacognostical identification to ensure the purity of raw materials.[see source text or glossary: Shaileya]
36) Pregnant:
Pregnant women are specifically mentioned regarding the use of Vasa, an herb that can cause abortions. Substituting this with Ashoka ensures safety while retaining its therapeutic benefits.[see source text or glossary: Pregnant]
37) Amalaki:
Amalaki (Emblica officinalis) is cited as a substitute for Bhallatak due to similar Rasayana properties, illustrating the concept of therapeutic substitution in Ayurveda.[see source text or glossary: Amalaki]
38) Disease:
Disease context and treatment are central to the use of Ayurvedic herbs. Ensuring the right plant materials through pharmacognostical identification helps in effectively managing diseases while preventing adulteration.[see source text or glossary: Disease]
39) Siddha:
Siddha refers to another traditional system of medicine that, like Ayurveda, can sometimes cause confusion in plant identities due to vernacular names, necessitating careful pharmacognostical studies.[see source text or glossary: Siddha]
40) Vipaka:
Vipaka refers to the post-digestive effect of a drug in Ayurveda, one of the factors considered when selecting substitute drugs to ensure similar therapeutic actions.[see source text or glossary: Vipaka]
41) Kumkum:
Kumkum, being a costly drug, is often substituted with Kusumbha to make Ayurvedic treatments more accessible while retaining efficacy.[see source text or glossary: Kumkum]
42) Laghu:
Laghu Gokshur refers to Tribulus terrestris, which is sometimes used as a substitute for other medicinal plants, showing the practice of substitution based on functional similarities.[see source text or glossary: Laghu]
43) Delhi:
Delhi is mentioned as the location of the Ministry of AYUSH, emphasizing the administrative and regulatory efforts in ensuring the quality of Ayurvedic medicines are upheld.[see source text or glossary: Delhi]
44) Lemon:
Lemon oils are sometimes adulterated with synthetic chemicals like citral to enhance their natural properties, demonstrating the need for stringent quality control and verification practices.[see source text or glossary: Lemon]
45) Sida (Shida):
Sida cordifolia is noted for being substituted with its whole plant instead of just the roots, illustrating part-for-whole substitution in Ayurvedic practice.[see source text or glossary: Sida]
46) Rasa (Rasha):
Rasa in Ayurveda refers to the taste of a drug, one of the key properties used in pharmacognostical identification to ensure the right medicinal plant is used in treatments.[see source text or glossary: Rasa]
47) Vasa (Vasha):
Vasa (Adhatoda vasica) is mentioned as having abortifacient effects, limiting its use in pregnant women and necessitating substitutes like Ashoka to ensure safe treatment options.[see source text or glossary: Vasa]
48) Guna:
Guna refers to the inherent qualities of a drug in Ayurveda, considered when selecting substitute drugs to ensure they provide similar therapeutic effects as the original.[see source text or glossary: Guna]
49) Hair:
Hair is referenced in the context of Nardostachys jatamansi, whose rhizomes are covered with tufts of brittle hairs, aiding in the pharmacognostical identification of the plant.[see source text or glossary: Hair]
Other Science Concepts:
Discover the significance of concepts within the article: 鈥�ID of Arjuna, Punarnava, Jatamansi: Substitution and Adulteration鈥�. Further sources in the context of Science might help you critically compare this page with similair documents:
Strategic planning, Quality assurance, Ayurvedic theories, Traditional System of Medicine, Regulatory guidelines, Pharmacognostical identification, Organoleptic study, Pharmacognostical characters, Adulteration and substitution, Knowledge sharing, Morphological similarity, Pharmaco-vigilance, Shelf life of drug.