365betÓéÀÖ

Significance of Mimamsaka argument

The Mimamsaka argument, a key concept in Tibetan Buddhism, encompasses a range of philosophical positions put forward by the Mimamsa school. This includes evaluating the understanding of Vedic texts, questioning their reliability based on the author's characteristics, and critiquing the role of external factors in establishing cognition. The argument also addresses the interpretation of sound and its relationship to sensory experience, emphasizing the significance of Vedic authority and the nature of rituals. Overall, the Mimamsaka argument explores the foundations of knowledge and the validity of Vedic assertions in philosophical discourse.

In Dutch: Mimamsaka argument; In Finnish: Mimamsaka argumentti; In Spanish: Argumento de Mimamsaka

The below excerpts are indicatory and do represent direct quotations or translations. It is your responsibility to fact check each reference.

Buddhist concept of 'Mimamsaka argument'

Buddhism Books

The Mimamsaka argument in Buddhism encompasses interpretations of Vedic texts, philosophical reasoning on the nature of reality, cognition, and the relationship between words and meaning, highlighting critiques on permanence, understanding, and validity within sacred texts.

Significance in Tibetan Buddhism (Vajrayana or tantric Buddhism):
Tibetan Buddhism Books

From: Tattvasangraha [with commentary]

(1) The Mimamsaka argument asserts that eternality is signified by the characters of being not produced and not destroyed, which do not require proof.[1] (2) A philosophical position or reasoning method presented to question or analyze assertions regarding comprehension and the nature of words.[2] (3) The reasoning that asserts that a source devoid of defects conducive to falsity is necessary for establishing true cognition.[3] (4) A philosophical discussion presented by the Mimamsaka school regarding the need for corroboration among cognitions.[4] (5) Debates posed by the Mimamsaka school of thought concerning the nature of dissolution and its effects.[5]

Tibetan Buddhism includes schools such as Nyingma, Kadampa, Kagyu and Gelug. Their primary canon of literature is divided in two broad categories: The Kangyur, which consists of Buddha’s words, and the Tengyur, which includes commentaries from various sources. Esotericism and tantra techniques (vajrayana) are collected indepently.

Hindu concept of 'Mimamsaka argument'

Hinduism Books

The Mimamsaka argument in Hinduism emphasizes the significance of obligatory rites within karma and posits that Vedic validity is independent of human origin, advocating for the necessity of rituals and rejecting the finality of destruction.

Significance in Vedanta (school of philosophy):
Vedanta Books

From: Taittiriya Upanishad Bhashya Vartika

(1) A philosophical debate asserting that evidence exists to support the emergence of positives from negatives.[6] (2) A philosophical standpoint that asserts the importance of obligatory rites in the context of karma, which is critiqued in the text.[7]

Vedanta refers to a school of orthodox Hindu philosophy (astika), drawing its subject-matter from the Upanishads. There are a number of sub-schools of Vedanta, however all of them expound on the basic teaching of the ultimate reality (brahman) and liberation (moksha) of the individual soul (atman).

Significance in Vyakarana (Sanskrit grammar):
Vyakarana Books

From: Vakyapadiya of Bhartrihari

(1) The reasoning and rationale put forth by followers of the Mimamsa philosophy to support their interpretations.[8]

Vyakarana refers to Sanskrit grammar and represents one of the six additional sciences (vedanga) to be studied along with the Vedas. Vyakarana concerns itself with the rules of Sanskrit grammar and linguistic analysis in order to establish the correct context of words and sentences.

Plural form: Mimamsaka arguments.